Change puts CMOs in the hot seat. A new product, market shift, or leadership shakeup doesn’t just demand speed – it demands clarity. And that clarity often starts with a brutal but necessary question: Do we need to reposition, or just refine?
These two moves are not interchangeable. One is a reset. The other is a recalibration. Knowing which lever to pull can mean the difference between momentum and misfire.
What’s the Difference?
Refining your messaging means sharpening what already works. You’re not tearing anything down. You’re tightening the bolts. Maybe your value prop is sound, but your tone is off. Maybe your customer language is outdated, or your differentiators are buried too deep.
Repositioning, on the other hand, means reframing the core story. You’re not tweaking; you’re rebuilding. That could mean targeting a different audience, solving a different problem, or even redefining what business you’re in.
Situations That Call for Refinement
Refinement is the smarter, faster path when the foundation is still strong. Here’s when it makes sense:
-
- You’re launching a product extension, not a reinvention.
-
- Your market hasn’t changed, but your audience has evolved.
-
- You’re hearing “We love what you do, but we didn’t know you did that.”
-
- Sales is using their own pitch because the core messaging doesn’t land.
Refinement is often about removing friction, making sure your messaging reflects your current strengths, not last year’s tagline.
When Repositioning Is Inevitable
Repositioning isn’t a light touch. It’s a strategic pivot. Consider it when:
-
- You’re entering a new market where your current story doesn’t translate.
-
- You’ve hired a new CEO with a different vision for the business.
-
- Your competitors are telling the same story you are – and winning.
-
- You’ve gone from product-led to platform-led, or vice versa.
In these cases, refining the language won’t cut it. The message isn’t just off, it’s wrong for where the company is headed.
How to Make the Call
If you’re unsure, pressure test your current messaging:
-
- Does it match how customers talk about your value?
-
- Does it help sales close deals, or slow them down?
-
- Does it reflect where you’re going, not just where you’ve been?
If the answers point to small disconnects, refine. If they reveal a bigger identity issue, reposition.
Final Word: Move with Intent
Too many brands jump to repositioning because it sounds bold. Others cling to outdated language out of fear. Don’t let urgency force you into the wrong move.
CMOs under pressure need more than speed. They need precision. Whether you refine or reposition, the goal is the same: messaging that earns trust, aligns your team, and accelerates growth.
Not sure if it’s time to refine or reposition? Let’s figure it out together.
#CMOLeadership #BrandStrategy #MessagingMatters #FinancialPR
